Categorized | Opinions

Smith: Furlough relief plan now up to BOE, HSTA

Reader Opinions Disclaimer: This column allows members of the community to share their opinions and views, which do not necessarily reflect those of Hawaii 24/7, its staff, sponsors or anyone other than the writer. Hawaii 24/7 reserves the right to refuse any column deemed to be misinformation, of an unethical nature, a personal attack, or a blatant commercial pitch.

(Linda Smith is senior policy advisor to Gov. Linda Lingle’s administration)

April 27, 2010

The opportunity to eliminate Furlough Fridays in the next school year has been made possible through the Legislature’s willingness to make available $67 million from the Hurricane Relief Fund for this purpose. These funds however do not address the elimination of the three remaining furlough days this school year. The opportunity to do so rests entirely with the Board of Education and the Hawaii State Teachers Association.

Unfortunately the chairman of the Board of Education and the leaders of the teachers’ union are not willing to take even the first step that will allow children back into the classroom for the remainder of this school year and the next.

Linda Smith

Governor Lingle, responding to teachers and principals who have expressed interest in ending furlough Fridays, suggested on Sunday that Department of Education personnel consider voluntarily returning to schools for the last three furlough days of this school year. As the Governor said, “This would be a welcome and significant gesture to heal our community.”

State law (Chapter 90, Hawaii Revised Statues) allows individuals and organizations to volunteer their time and talents to help the public. Many dedicated DOE employees already volunteer their time to help out before and after school and with many school-related activities outside of their normal teaching assignments. These individuals give generously of their time and talents and we are thankful that they do so.

While federal labor laws place limits on some hourly public workers that limit their ability to volunteer for work they perform in their normal paid capacity, the Department of Education could easily identify these individuals and process appropriate compensation for the additional hours they give back to allow children to return to the classroom.

We know however, that decisions can be made at each school to return on certain furlough days. Late last year parents, teachers and school administrators at 184 of the 256 public schools decided to eliminate one or more furlough days by giving up non-instructional days.

We also know that 17 public charter schools voted against taking furloughs. These actions are commendable and demonstrate that teachers and school staff members are able to make decisions in the best interests of the children.

Volunteering to provide three days of service on behalf of the children and tax payers of our state can make it possible to recover what will otherwise be lost educational days in the remaining time of this year.

Rather than deride the Governor’s recommendation and continue their opposition toward reasonable, responsible and fiscally prudent solutions, the HSTA and BOE continue to fight the financial reality facing this state.

Across the country, schools are struggling to sustain educational opportunities despite the financial crisis that has necessitated reductions in education funding and classroom hours in addition to massive teacher layoffs.

In order to cope with this situation during these difficult times, sacrifice and volunteerism combined with the reasonable expenditure of limited state funds offer opportunities to alleviate the furlough situation we face today.

The Governor is willing to allow the DOE to decide who their critical employees are but the union and the chair of the BOE feel otherwise.

But if they are reasonable and realistic, solutions are available. In short, where there is a will there is way. The HSTA and the chairman of the BOE are saying “no way; no can” at the very moment when the community needs to hear “yes we can and yes we will.”

How sad.

Linda Smith
Senior Advisor – Policy, Office of the Governor

2 Responses to “Smith: Furlough relief plan now up to BOE, HSTA”

  1. Joann says:

    Holy Smokes! I can’t speak for all teachers but I know my children’s have worked extremely hard over the past year to make up for a month and a half worth of lost instructional days. Their school has been turned upside down managing other budget and program cuts that the school administration has juggled with grace and concern. To ask them to cobble together volunteer days seems outright mean to me. It is apparent that the Governor has little value for public education and public educators in all she has said and done this past year. That is too bad, we love our teachers and our Hawaii public school. To ask schools across the state to run on a volunteer basis is frightening to me. What about all the support staff? School is not like a scouts meeting. I would feel very uncomfortable dropping my child off at a school on staff volunteer day?! I mentioned this idea of running schools on a volunteer basis to balance the budget to friends and family in other states and they said it sounded like a banana republic. It does.
    Despite what the Governor seems to think, cutting funding to education does not equal education reform. I know she is excited about getting her constitutional amendment on the ballot but the reality is we all, parents, teachers, children could use more leadership, concern and inspiration from the community to help guide us through these dramatic cuts in funding. Instead of publicly pitting “tax payers” against public education and defending budget cuts…Will the Governor volunteer to do her part on the front lines? Maybe help in a classroom or tutor in the after school program?

  2. STEVE says:

    My question to Linda… what is good for the goose is good for the gander. I suspect that the teachers might be more willing to volunteer two days of free instruction if all State of Hawaii government employees will also agree to volunteer two days of free labor in their own roles. It seems like such an expression of good will would save the State a fair amount of money (two days’ pay). Has this suggestion been proposed?


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: